Shelf corporation or LLC: which US entity should a non-resident buy?
Both are available off the shelf in every state. The choice depends on who will own the company, whether it will raise money and how profits will leave the USA.
The short answer
Buy an LLC if you are one or a few owners running a trading, online or holding business and want the simplest structure. Buy a C-corporation if you expect US investors, stock options or a future sale, or if you want a clean wall between US corporate tax and your personal position at home. Most non-resident buyers of shelf companies choose an LLC; most who plan to raise venture money choose a Delaware corporation.
How each is taxed at federal level
- C-corporation: pays US federal corporate income tax on its profits; dividends to a foreign owner are then subject to withholding tax, reduced by any treaty. Two layers, but predictable, and the owner's home-country position is usually simpler.
- Single-member LLC owned by a non-resident: disregarded for federal income tax; the owner is taxed directly on any US-connected income and files a US return only if there is such income, but the LLC itself must still file an information return (Form 5472 with a pro-forma 1120) each year, with heavy penalties for missing it.
- Multi-member LLC: treated as a partnership; the LLC withholds tax on foreign partners' share of US-connected income.
- State tax depends on where the company is registered and where it operates, not just on the entity type.
Formalities and running costs
| LLC | C-corporation | |
|---|---|---|
| Governing document | Operating agreement, private | Bylaws plus board and shareholder minutes |
| Officers required | Managers or members only | Directors and officers, annual meetings |
| Ownership record | Membership ledger, usually private | Stock ledger; some states list officers publicly |
| Annual filings | Annual report or licence fee in most states | Annual report plus franchise tax in several states |
| Federal returns for a foreign-owned company | Form 5472 information return (single-member) or partnership return | Form 1120 corporate return |
| Investor familiarity | Moderate | Highest, especially Delaware |
Investors, options and exits
Venture investors and accelerators in the USA expect a Delaware C-corporation with a standard capitalisation table, and they will usually require a conversion if you arrive with an LLC. Stock option plans are built around corporations. If raising US money is on your roadmap within two years, start with the corporation and avoid the conversion cost later.
Banking and payment processing
Banks and card processors accept both entity types. What they look at is the owner's identification, the EIN, the formation documents and a coherent description of the business. A corporation with a board resolution authorising the account can be marginally easier at traditional banks; fintech providers treat both alike.
Buying off the shelf
Shelf LLCs and shelf corporations are transferred differently: an LLC by assignment of membership interest and a new operating agreement, a corporation by stock transfer, new bylaws and new directors and officers. Both take days once due diligence is complete. Check whether the company already holds an EIN, and if so that no returns are outstanding.
Next step
Browse US shelf corporations by state, or read the Delaware vs Wyoming comparison and the EIN and banking guide. This is general information; take US tax advice before you trade.
This guide is general information, not legal or tax advice. Rules differ by country and change over time.
Related guides
Ready to take ownership of your company?
Tell us the jurisdiction, age and timeline you need. We reply with current availability and a written quotation.